🍕 Best Pizza in Guelph (2025 Guide): 9 Local Spots Worth Trying
When it comes to finding the best pizza in Guelph, locals know best. As a family of five born-and-raised Guelphites, we’ve taste-tested just about every slice this city has to offer. Whether you are after a quick takeout, authentic Neapolitan, or something gourmet and creative, this list covers the top pizzerias in town!
Let’s dive into Guelph’s pizza scene for 2025.
9. Pizza Express – 672 Woolwich St Unit 4
📞 519-265-9299 | 🌐 mypizzaexpress.ca
A reader’s choice pick, Pizza Express came highly recommended (twice in one month!)—so of course, we had to try it. Located across from Riverside Park, Pizza Express keeps things simple with pizza, wings, garlic bread, meal deals (try “The Hulk”), and desserts.
✅ Best for: Delivery
💲 Price: $$
📲 Order online: Yes
8. Piatto Pizzeria – 153 Wyndham St N
📞 519-826-0449 | 🌐 piattopizzeria.com
Piatto is one of Guelph’s newest additions, bringing an authentic Neapolitan pizza experience certified by the Associazione Verace Pizza Napoletana (VPN). Ingredients and preparation follow true Italian tradition, and the vibe inside is cozy yet lively.
Reservations are recommended—it’s become a hotspot since opening.
✅ Best for: Dine-in
💲 Price: $$$$
📲 Order online: No
7. The Real Deal Sports Bar – 224 Victoria Rd S
📞 519-763-7325 | 🌐 therealdealsportsbar.com
A local favourite with a near cult following, The Real Deal combines sports-bar energy with surprisingly delicious pizza. The difference here is in the sauce and toppings quality, which many argue makes it the most authentic Italian-style pizza in town. Bonus: it’s also a full sports bar with beer, food, billiards, and even merch.
✅ Best for: Dine-in
💲 Price: $$$
📲 Order online: No
6. Pizza Trokadero – 7 Municipal St
📞 519-829-2444 | 🌐 trokaderoguelph.ca
Trokadero stands out for its Mediterranean-inspired “gourmet” pizzas with toppings like sundried tomatoes, prosciutto, artichokes, and even broccoli. Every pizza starts with house-made dough and signature sauce, making each bite feel intentional. It’s a healthier-feeling take on pizza—though let’s be honest, it’s still pizza.
✅ Best for: Takeout
💲 Price: $$$
📲 Order online: No
5. Tito’s Pizzeria – 51 Dovercliffe Rd
📞 519-780-0808 | 🌐 titospizzaguelph.ca
Don’t let the unassuming exterior fool you—Tito’s has been a west-side Guelph favourite for years. Open 365 days a year, this family-run shop delivers hearty pizzas, panzerottis, wings, garlic bread, cheesecake, and even lasagna. Customers rave about their generous toppings and great value.
✅ Best for: Takeout or delivery
💲 Price: $$
📲 Order online: Yes
4. Earth to Table: Bread Bar – 105 Gordon St
📞 519-767-2999 | 🌐 breadbar.ca
Bread Bar isn’t just a pizza joint—it’s a downtown Guelph restaurant known for its creative, doughy pizzas like “Hogs and Kisses” and “The Bee Sting.” With its trendy vibe and sit-down dining, this is the place for a pizza night out rather than quick takeout.
✅ Best for: Dine-in
💲 Price: $$$$
📲 Order online: No
3. Victoria’s Pizza – 259 Grange Rd & 210 Kortright Rd W
📞 519-821-1000 / 519-836-5000 | 🌐 victoriaspizzaguelph.com
With two locations, Victoria’s has built a loyal following. Known for saucier pizzas with generous toppings, they’re also accommodating with custom orders—perfect for families where no one agrees on toppings. Their menu goes beyond pizza to include wings, panzerottis, garlic bread, and fries.
✅ Best for: Takeout
💲 Price: $$
📲 Order online: Yes
2. Dynamite Pizza – 15 Speedvale Ave E
📞 519-824-8808 | 🌐 dynamitepizzaguelph.com
Affordable, reliable, and family-friendly, Dynamite Pizza is the everyday go-to spot for many locals. The staff is friendly, the pizzas are customizable (perfect for half-and-half family orders), and they also offer wings and panzerottis. It’s not a dine-in place, but for quick takeout, it’s a winner.
✅ Best for: Takeout
💲 Price: $$
📲 Order online: Yes
1. Roy’s Pizza – 48 Macdonell St (inside Jimmy Jazz Bar)
📞 519-265-0501 | 🌐 royspizza519.ca
Tucked inside Jimmy Jazz bar downtown, Roy’s popped up during the pandemic and quickly earned its spot as a hidden gem. Known for creative ingredient blends and bold flavours, it’s become the go-to for those craving something different.
Ryan’s favourite? The Double Roni.
✅ Best for: Takeout
💲 Price: $$$$
📲 Order online: Yes
🍕 Final Thoughts: Where’s the Best Pizza in Guelph?
From authentic Neapolitan pies at Piatto, to creative hidden gems like Roy’s, Guelph’s pizza scene has grown into something for every taste and budget. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, these nine pizzerias showcase the best of what the city has to offer in 2025.
Did we miss one?
If you’ve read this and think we need to add another to the list, just let us know (it also gives us an excuse to go out for more pizza..). Need help with a house? We’re Guelph real estate agents that know our city well and can help you, too.!